Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Foodrecipes

My First Sourdough Bread

What I Learned Using The Perfect Loaf

Seeded Sourdough Bread
My First Sourdough Bread 9

I have finally joined the sourdough club.

After years of enjoying good bread, I decided it was time to find out what all the fuss was about. So, rather than simply buying another loaf from the bakery, I decided to make my own sourdough bread.

There was just one small problem.

I had never made sourdough before.

I soon discovered that sourdough is not simply a case of mixing flour, water, and salt, putting it in the oven, and hoping for the best. There is a whole world of starters, fermentation, hydration, folding, proving and shaping.

Thankfully, I had some help.

For my first attempt, I followed the methods and advice of Maurizio Leo, the baker behind The Perfect Loaf. His book, The Perfect Loaf, became my guide as I worked my way through the process.

And, surprisingly, I actually ended up with a loaf of bread.

Why I chose The Perfect Loaf

The Perfect Loaf
The Perfect Loaf

There are plenty of sourdough recipes online. However, I wanted something that explained why I was doing each stage rather than simply giving me a list of instructions.

That is what attracted me to Maurizio Leo’s approach.

His website, The Perfect Loaf, is packed with sourdough guides, recipes, and explanations. His cookbook takes the same approach, starting with the fundamentals before moving into different breads and more advanced techniques.

The book covers everything from creating a sourdough starter to baking bread, pizza, focaccia, rolls, and even sourdough-based sweet treats. It contains 60 recipes, so there is plenty to keep a new baker busy.

Affiliate link: Buy Maurizio Leo’s The Perfect Loaf cookbook on Amazon.

For a complete beginner like me, having the book on the kitchen worktop was useful. I could read through the process, check what should happen next and, most importantly, understand what I was actually trying to achieve.

So, what exactly is a sourdough starter?

what exactly is a sourdough starter
What exactly is a sourdough starter

This was probably the biggest mystery for me.

A sourdough starter is essentially a living mixture of flour and water. Naturally occurring yeasts and bacteria begin to ferment the mixture.

Over time, the starter becomes active. It develops bubbles, increases in volume, and develops that distinctive slightly sour smell.

That starter becomes the natural leavening agent for the bread.

In other words, instead of reaching for a packet of commercial yeast, you use your active sourdough starter to help the dough rise.

Creating a starter from scratch takes several days. The Perfect Loaf says a new starter can take around five to seven days to get going, although the exact timing depends on conditions such as temperature and feeding.

This is where sourdough starts to feel less like baking and more like looking after a very small, slightly demanding pet.

You feed it.

You watch it.

You check whether it has risen.

And then you wonder whether it is hungry again.

Feeding the sourdough starter

Keeping the starter active is an important part of sourdough baking.

You don’t simply make it once and leave it sitting in the cupboard.

The starter needs regular feeding with fresh flour and water. This gives the microorganisms inside it fresh food and allows fermentation to continue.

When the starter is active and ready to bake with, you should see signs of fermentation. It should rise after feeding and develop bubbles.

The Perfect Loaf has a particularly useful collection of guides explaining starter maintenance and common starter problems.

I quickly learnt that temperature matters too.

Maurizio Leo even admits that he is unusually obsessed with temperature. After making my first loaf, I can understand why.

Sourdough has a mind of its own.

Making the sourdough dough

Once the starter was ready, it was time to make bread.

This is where things become rather different from making an ordinary loaf.

You are dealing with hydration, fermentation, and gluten development. The dough can feel quite wet and sticky at first.

That is where patience becomes important.

Instead of simply kneading the dough for several minutes, sourdough often involves a series of folds during the early stages of fermentation.

The idea is to develop strength in the dough without aggressively kneading it.

At this stage, I began to appreciate why having a good sourdough book was useful.

There is a lot happening inside that bowl.

The flour absorbs the water. Fermentation begins. Gluten develops. The dough gradually becomes stronger and more elastic.

And you wait.

Then you wait some more.

What is bulk fermentation?

One of the terms you quickly encounter when making sourdough is bulk fermentation.

This is the period when the dough ferments after mixing.

It is an important stage because the dough needs time to develop structure, flavour, and gas.

The tricky part is that there isn’t always one magic number of hours that works for every kitchen.

Temperature, starter activity, flour and hydration can all affect how quickly the dough ferments.

That means you cannot always rely on the clock.

You need to look at the dough.

That was one of the biggest lessons from my first loaf.

Shaping the sourdough

Shaping the sourdough
Shaping the sourdough

Eventually, the dough needs shaping.

This was another new experience.

The aim is to create enough tension in the outside of the dough to help it hold its shape during its final proof and baking.

It feels slightly strange at first.

The dough is soft.

It is sticky.

You are trying not to knock all the air out of it.

And yet somehow you are expected to turn it into a neat little loaf.

My first attempt certainly wasn’t going to win any prizes for perfect shaping.

But it looked like bread.

And that was enough for me. Prove in a basket, which I bought. Affiliate link: Amazon

Why bake sourdough in a Dutch oven?

This was another part of the process I had never really considered.

Why put bread inside a heavy cooking pot?

It turns out there is a very good reason.

A Dutch oven traps steam released from the dough during the early part of baking. That humid environment helps the loaf expand before the crust sets.

It also helps produce the attractive crust that many people associate with artisan sourdough bread.

The Perfect Loaf explains that the sealed environment created by a Dutch oven makes introducing steam in a normal home oven much easier.

That makes a Dutch oven a very useful piece of equipment for home sourdough baking.

And, thankfully, it isn’t only useful for bread.

Once you have bought one, you can use it for stews, casseroles, soups, and plenty of other dishes.

So I don’t feel quite so guilty about adding another piece of kitchen equipment to the cupboard.

Again, I bought my Dutch Oven from an Amazon Affiliate link

Choosing a Dutch oven for sourdough

You don’t necessarily need the most expensive Dutch oven you can find.

What matters is having a pot that can withstand the high temperatures needed for bread baking and has a suitable size and shape for your loaf.

A 5- to 6-quart Dutch oven is a common size for sourdough baking.

You also need to consider whether you want an enamelled Dutch oven or bare cast iron.

For a home kitchen, an enamelled model is convenient because it is versatile and relatively easy to clean. However, there are plenty of options available.

Affiliate link: See my recommended Dutch ovens for baking sourdough on Amazon.

If you are buying one specifically for bread, check the manufacturer’s maximum temperature before using it in a very hot oven.

Finally, into the oven

This was the exciting bit.

After all the feeding, mixing, folding, fermenting, and shaping, the sourdough was finally ready for the oven.

I carefully transferred the dough into the hot Dutch oven.

Then came the scoring.

A sharp blade is used to make a cut across the surface of the dough. This gives the expanding loaf somewhere to open as it rises.

Lid on.

Into the oven.

And now the hardest part of sourdough baking.

Waiting.

The moment I opened the Dutch oven

When I finally removed the lid, I had one of those small kitchen moments that make all the effort worthwhile.

There it was.

My first homemade sourdough loaf.

The crust had developed a lovely colour, and the loaf had risen.

Was it perfect?

Absolutely not.

But it was mine.

And I had made it from flour, water, salt, and a sourdough starter.

That felt pretty good.

What I learned from making my first sourdough

Sourdough focaccia sandwich
Sourdough focaccia sandwich

The biggest surprise was how much there is to learn.

Before starting, I thought sourdough was basically about following a recipe.

It isn’t.

The recipe gives you a framework. However, you also need to understand what the dough is telling you.

Is the starter active?

Has the dough fermented enough?

Does it feel strong enough?

Is it ready to shape?

Those questions become increasingly important.

I also learnt that sourdough takes patience.

You can’t really rush fermentation.

Well, you can try.

The bread will probably let you know whether that was a good idea.

Would I make sourdough again?

Sourdough focaccia with Rosemary Basil and Tomatoes
Sourdough focaccia with Rosemary, Basil and Tomatoes

Definitely.

My first loaf has given me the confidence to try again. The great thing about sourdough is that every loaf gives you another opportunity to learn.

Perhaps the next one will have a better shape.

Maybe I’ll get a more open crumb.

Perhaps I’ll improve my scoring.

And, eventually, I might even stop checking the oven every five minutes.

For anyone thinking about making their first sourdough bread, I would recommend doing some reading before starting.

Maurizio Leo’s The Perfect Loaf was the book I used for my first attempt, and I found having a detailed guide particularly useful. The book has also been recognised with both the 2023 James Beard Foundation Award for Bread and an IACP Cookbook Award.

You can also find a huge amount of free sourdough information on The Perfect Loaf website, including guides for beginners, sourdough starters and baking bread in a Dutch oven.

My sourdough baking essentials

If you are thinking about having a go yourself, you don’t need to fill the kitchen with expensive equipment.

I’d start with:

  • A good kitchen scale
  • A large mixing bowl
  • A sourdough starter
  • Good bread flour
  • A dough scraper
  • A proofing basket
  • A sharp bread lame or scoring blade
  • Baking paper
  • A suitable Dutch oven
  • And, importantly, plenty of patience
  • All available on Amazon Affiliate link: 

The kitchen scale is particularly important because sourdough recipes are usually based on precise weights rather than measuring cups.

My first sourdough verdict

Sourdough Pizza
Sourdough Pizza

Making sourdough bread for the first time was much more interesting than I expected.

There is something satisfying about taking a few simple ingredients and turning them into a proper loaf of bread.

It is also a surprisingly slow process.

But that is part of the appeal.

You cannot simply press a button and expect perfect sourdough.

You have to get involved.

You feed the starter. You mix the dough. You fold it. You watch it ferment. You shape it. Then you put it into a screaming-hot Dutch oven and hope you have done everything correctly.

And when you finally cut into it, you get to find out.

My first sourdough loaf wasn’t perfect.

But it was delicious.

And once I had made that first loaf, I wanted to see what else I could do with the starter.

That led to sourdough pizza, which was every bit as enjoyable to make and even better to eat. I also made a sourdough focaccia topped with rosemary, basil, and tomatoes. It was a completely different bread, but it showed just how versatile sourdough can be.

Then there were the sourdough pancakes.

These were made using the discard from the starter, turning something that might otherwise have been thrown away into another tasty breakfast.

So, what started with one loaf of sourdough bread quickly became pizza, focaccia and pancakes.

I have a feeling this is only the beginning.

What is sourdough discard?

One of the other things I discovered while making sourdough is discard.

When you feed your sourdough starter, you normally remove some of the existing starter before adding fresh flour and water. This is known as sourdough discard.

At first, I thought this simply meant throwing it away. However, you can actually use the discard in plenty of different recipes.

It can be added to pancakes, waffles, crackers, muffins and other baked treats. It gives recipes a slightly tangy flavour and is a great way of using up something that would otherwise end up in the bin.

So, I decided to give it a try. Quite a few times.

Making sourdough discard pancakes

Rather than waste my sourdough discard, I decided to make pancakes.

This was another first for me, and it seemed a good way to see what else I could do with my starter.

The pancakes turned out really well. They had a lovely light texture with a subtle tang from the sourdough.

I was also pleased that I had found another use for the discard. After all the work involved in keeping a sourdough starter alive, it seems a shame to throw any of it away.

So now I have homemade sourdough bread and sourdough pancakes to look forward to.

I think the starter may be becoming a permanent resident in my kitchen.

Pan Con Tomate

Avatar of John

John

Author of this Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blogarama - Blog Directory